Skip to main content

Libertarian Theologies: the French & American Revolutions

Recently the West has seen a resurgence in Libertarian politics. We should be happy for this. But we need to be happy in a qualified way. Even the term means different things to different people and while Libertarian principles can be rooted in a godly worldview, it can also be rooted in an ungodly one.

By Libertarianism, we’re meaning a political system focused on the liberty of the individual from the State. People who identify this way aren’t so concerned about the Right/Left political divide as much as the Big/Small government divide. 

Here in the UK we can see a form Libertarianism in the Green party who would make marijuana and brothels legal – a matter of individual conscience. We also see it another form in the Welsh national party that wants to dissolve central powers away from Westminster into more regional zones. While the Tories are mostly NOT Libertarian – certainly not Theresa May who wants the right to read your WhatsApp messages – there are some voices within the party, such as Daniel Hannan, who are. In the USA, Rand Paul would be similar to Hannan – a lone Republican voice calling his party and country to Libertarian principles.

Christian theology and Libertarianism

Christians should rightly be wary of big, intrusive government. We should do so based on our knowledge of human nature as corrupted by sin. Historically they tend to erode religious liberty. Even in the secular world, we are familiar with the phrase “power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely.” It’s this understanding of man’s sinful nature that made the difference between the American and the French revolutions, both of which happened around the same time, but which had very different results.

The French Revolution was fuelled by the idea that Monarchy is bad. The American Revolution was fuelled by the idea that Mankind is bad. This is why the American colonies went from revolution to peacefully building the longest lasting republic while the French fell into a Reign of Terror that was somewhere north of a blood bath.

There is a type of Libertarianism that sees man as essentially good, but he is oppressed by some sort of abstract system called "government". But there is another type of Libertarianism that sees man as broken because of sin. Because of this condition, political power should be spread out as widely as possible – hence America’s separation of federal powers, balance between federal and state’s authority, written Bill of Rights, etc.


An unsanctified Libertarianism sees government as bad because it's government. A Christian view sees government as bad because it is human.

The difference between the Revolutionary French vision of Liberty and the Colonial American vision of Liberty was that one didn’t take sin seriously and the other did. Once freed from the Monarchy, the French were shocked to find that sin and evil were still with them. For, to the ungodly, Liberty can simply be code for “I can do whatever I want.”

For those of us who embrace Libertarian ideals, let's remember Satan’s words to the fallen angels in Milton’s Paradise Lost when they finally arrive in hell, "Here at least we shall be free!” 

Why we need [some] Government

This is also why the Christian view is not compatible with the forms of Libertarianism that are akin to anarchy.

Some Libertarians think that mankind needs government like a fish needs a bicycle. If you’d like to read a Christian advocating anarchy, see HERE.  I don’t think this article is entirely wrong – but it’s unbalanced in its exposition of Scripture. He cites some verses but leaves out some others. If we look at the full counsel of what Scripture says on the matter, we see the Bible creates a tension when it comes to its view on government. It’s is neither na├»ve in embracing it nor is it completely dismissive of it.

God’s Kingdom will ultimately subvert every government that does not confess Jesus as Lord – and Christians, as citizens of heaven, should resist ungodly laws. But until Christ’s Kingdom comes in power, there must be some government because here is still human sin which tends towards lawlessness. The church is called by God to preach the gospel and care for the poor. Civil governments are called by God to wield the sword in order to protect the innocent and punish evildoers. Read what Paul writes carefully…

The one in authority is God’s servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for rulers do not bear the sword for no reason. They are God’s servants, agents of wrath to bring punishment on the wrongdoer. Therefore, it is necessary to submit to the authorities.
 –Romans 13.4

All leaders will give an account to God for how they governed (Psalm 2). It will be a scary day for many of them as they’ll have to give an account of what they did with the authority entrusted to them. Though this should strike fear in the hearts of leaders – it should also remind us that all authority, including civil authority, comes from God and should not be despised outright.

Nearly ten years ago, a Western coalition of nations took out Saddam Hussein in a cloud of talk about liberating the Iraqi people. And for good reason - he was an oppressive and brutal tyrant. But what happened when he was removed? The anarchy that ensued was worse than the dictator. Honour and revenge killings, looting, rape, etc. No police were around to protect the innocent.

This world's ultimate problem is a not a politico failing, but rather a cardio failing. Bad men in good systems will still create painful living. So though we can't agree that Libertarianism will solve all of the world's ills, we may rightly agree that they will protect us from the abuse of overreaching government.

And we still need some government in place to protect us from the abuse of our overreaching neighbours.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Where I Turn Down a Gay 'Wedding' Invitation

Dear Katie,
I hope this letter finds you well. You’ve been in my mind lately as it’s been a few weeks since we’ve met up. We’re overdue to grab a coffee – I hope we can soon.
I also want to thank you for thinking of me as you sent out invitations for what I know will be a big day for you and Joanna. I’ve known you since before you met her (two years ago now is it?) and I appreciate all you’ve shared with me about how meaningful that relationship is to you. 

I received the invitation for your ceremony. Thank you. It was kind of you and Joanna to think of me, especially since you know that I have a Christian faith. You've never directly asked me my views on gender or sexuality. But I think our conversations must have touched on it enough times to at least make you a bit unsure of my reaction when you sent the invitation.

I have to say 'no' to your kind invitation. You know that I care for you and that I value our friendship. You know I don't reject you because you are gay. T…

Is Jesus Really Silent about Homosexuality?

For non-Christians, this seems an odd debate. After all, mainstream society sees gender, marriage and sexuality as a form of individual self-actualisation and believes that one should be free to express these things however they wish – so long as they don’t hurt others. To people who aren’t Christian the whole discussion seems soooooo last millennia. But we Christians are foreigners to this world. 

Many of us don't have personalities that naturally enjoy debate. But as there are those who – in the name of Christ – are saying we need to adjust our teaching to the new LGBTQ ideology, then debate is upon us whether we like it or not.
In any debate involving people’s lives, points of view need to be expressed both sensitively and accurately - especially this one. Misinformation – however well intended – helps no one in the long run. That’s why it’s important to access popular sound bites that are often used in social media discussions to determine their truthfulness. One such is the lin…

Holy Halloween?

The big ugly debate is upon us.
No, not the Presidential one. This debate involves dwarves and banshees of quite another variety.
As heated as the political scene may now be, it will pale to fervor with which Christians will begin debating if and how they will celebrate what is now commonly called "Halloween". This battle of ideas will be waged from the beaches of church pews to the hills of Facebook. There will be shots fired and people unfriended.
But what cyber surfing culture warrior would be complete without some historical trivia and theological sanity? Here you go...

The Background Story
The devil would love to steal All Hallow’s Eve (Halloween) away from Christians. He is making good progress at it too.
All Hallow’s Eve is neither American nor pagan in heritage. The name should be obvious enough. Hallow means ‘holy’ (‘Hallowed be thy name’) and it marks a three-day celebration of the victory of Jesus over the powers of darkness as experienced by departed saints and Christi…